Crowell v. Butts

In this replevin action, a tenant sued his landlord and a towing company, alleging wrongful possession of several vehicles towed from the property he leased from the landlord. The County Court granted the defendants' motion for involuntary dismissal, and also found that the landlord's use of self-help was lawful. The Circuit Court affirmed. Finding that the plaintiff presented sufficient evidence to maintain the replevin action, the Court of Appeals reversed and remanded the replevin action for a trial de novo between the plaintiff and the towing company. It also found the landlord's use of self-help to be unlawful, and reversed and rendered that issue in favor of the plaintiff. Because the Supreme Court find that both the trial court and the Court of Appeals improperly addressed the issue of the landlord's use of self-help, it reversed the judgments and remanded the replevin action to the trial court for a trial de novo.View "Crowell v. Butts" on Justia Law